In December 2025, the White House told the states to back off AI rules. Ten months later, the states had passed more than 100 AI laws anyway. That is the preemption fight in one line: a federal government trying to clear the field, and state legislatures that keep planting new rules in it. Here is what each side actually did, who is paying for the fight, and what it means for you.

What Washington actually did
On December 11, 2025, President Trump signed Executive Order 14365, titled “Ensuring a National Policy Framework for Artificial Intelligence.” It did not create federal AI rules. It trained the federal government on the state ones.
The order did four things:
- A DOJ “AI Litigation Task Force.” The Justice Department was told to stand up a team within 30 days to challenge state AI laws in court, on Commerce Clause and preemption grounds.
- A Commerce Department watchlist. The Secretary of Commerce was ordered to publish an evaluation naming state AI laws deemed “onerous,” especially any that force AI to alter “truthful outputs.”
- A broadband money threat. States on that list could lose their share of the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program, roughly $21 billion in non-deployment funds.
- Side levers. The FCC and FTC were pointed toward their own preemption moves, on AI disclosure and on unfair-practices law.
Notice what is missing: a federal AI statute. Congress has never passed one. So the administration is trying to knock down state law without a federal law to replace it. Legal scholars have called that a gamble. The Benton Institute for Broadband and Society argued in April 2026 that the BEAD condition is unlawful outright, because it conflicts with the broadband law Congress actually wrote.

The lawsuits: xAI against Colorado
The task force stopped being an org chart in April. On April 9, 2026, Elon Musk’s xAI sued Colorado Attorney General Philip Weiser in federal court, challenging the Colorado AI Act (SB 24-205) on six counts, including First Amendment, Equal Protection, and Dormant Commerce Clause grounds.
Two weeks later, the federal government did something unusual. On April 24, 2026, a judge let the United States intervene as a plaintiff in the case. Then came the practical effect. On April 27, a stipulated order paused Colorado’s enforcement of the law while xAI prepares a preliminary injunction motion.
That pause is the whole strategy in miniature. No ruling on the merits. No precedent. Just delay, while the case grinds along. As of October 1, 2026, the docket still showed no injunction motion and no ruling.
Colorado responded by rewriting its own law. Governor Jared Polis signed SB 26-189 on May 14, 2026. It repeals and replaces the 2024 act, pushes the effective date to January 1, 2027, and swaps the duty of care, impact assessments, and risk-management program for narrower disclosure rules.
The bill: a three-year freeze
In June 2026, two House members, Jay Obernolte (R-Calif.) and Lori Trahan (D-Mass.), circulated a discussion draft called the Great American Artificial Intelligence Act, or GAAIA.
It has two halves.
- The framework. Frontier developers above $500 million in annual revenue would have to publish safety frameworks, report critical incidents, and submit to third-party audits.
- The freeze. States would be barred from regulating the development of AI models for three years, while keeping authority over deployment and use.
That second half is the fight. Supporters say one national standard beats fifty. Critics say the bill takes the current floor on state AI legislation and turns it into a federal ceiling. That was the exact wording from Brad Carson of Americans for Responsible Innovation in June 2026.
One important caveat: it is still a draft, not a bill. It has not been formally introduced. Together with the GUARDRAILS Act, introduced in March 2026 by Rep. Don Beyer and other Democrats to repeal the executive order outright, Congress has produced plenty of paper and no law.

Who is paying for the fight
This is where the lobbying shows up, and the numbers are large.
Across all industries, federal lobbying hit a record $1.4 billion in the first quarter of 2026, the highest first-quarter total since quarterly reporting began in 2008, according to OpenSecrets. Spending stayed near record levels in the second quarter.
The AI labs are now major players in their own right. OpenAI and Anthropic together spent $3.17 million on federal lobbying in Q2 2026, up 23 percent from the first quarter, per CNBC’s read of the disclosure filings. Anthropic spent $1.97 million and even outspent Nvidia for the quarter. OpenAI spent $1.2 million, close to Nvidia’s $1.25 million.
Outside spending is the other half. Corporate super PAC spending in the 2026 midterms passed the entire 2024 presidential cycle by 12 percent, with crypto and AI topping the list at over half a billion dollars, according to Public Citizen. As The Atlantic and others have reported, crypto alone has spent more than $200 million this cycle. AI money is right behind it.

Who is winning so far
The states, on volume. As of July 1, 2026, states had enacted 109 AI laws and 28 data-center laws this term, according to TechPolicy.Press, with 29 states passing AI legislation so far in 2026. A mid-year report from the Transparency Coalition counted 84 new AI laws across 27 states in the first half of the year, including 14 chatbot-safety measures in 13 states.
Washington, on direction. The same analysis found that federal pressure may have changed what states passed, nudging them toward child safety, data centers, and consumer protection, the carve-outs the executive order named as off limits. The freeze itself has stalled, and no standalone federal challenge to California or Texas has landed yet.
The practical state of play: state law is what governs most AI use today, and it is still unsettled.
What this means for you
- Your job. Illinois now treats AI that discriminates in hiring as a civil rights violation, with a notice requirement. That is a state law, and it applies today. The same screening problem is the subject of our earlier look at how AI hiring screens work.
- What you see online. California’s AI Transparency Act, live since August 2, 2026, requires large generative AI providers to offer detection tools and embed machine-readable markers in content.
- Health and kids. Missouri’s ban on AI therapy chatbots took effect August 28, 2026. More states are moving on companion chatbots.
- What is not protected. The freeze targets how models are built, not how they are used. That is the line most people cannot see, and it is the one to watch.
What to watch next
Three dates and one bill.
- The Colorado rulemaking. Comments close October 26, 2026, and xAI’s injunction motion waits on the final rules.
- A federal challenge to California. Analysts expect the DOJ to file against SB 53 or AB 2013 before the year ends. So far, it has not. Treat that as a forecast, not a fact.
- GAAIA moving from draft to introduced bill. That step tells you whose interests won.
The patchwork this fight is about
Preemption would wipe out a state-by-state set of AI disclosure rules overnight. We mapped the ones that already govern political ads, and who actually has to label synthetic campaign content.
FAQ
Does the federal government have an AI law?
No. There is no comprehensive federal AI statute. That is exactly why the preemption push is contested: it aims to override state law without a federal law on the books to replace it.
Are state AI laws still being enforced?
Mostly yes. California’s and Texas’s AI laws are live. Colorado’s enforcement is paused while xAI’s case proceeds. New York’s frontier-safety law starts January 1, 2027.
Can Washington really cut broadband money over state AI laws?
It has threatened to, through the BEAD program. Legal analysts, including the Benton Institute, say the condition is likely unlawful. As of this writing, no list has been enforced.
What is the difference between preempting development and preempting use?
Development covers how a model is built and trained. Use covers how it is deployed, for example in hiring or lending. The GAAIA draft freezes the first and leaves the second to the states.
The Short Version
- December 11, 2025: Trump signed EO 14365, ordering a DOJ task force and a Commerce watchlist, with BEAD broadband money as the lever.
- April 2026: xAI sued Colorado over its AI Act, the US intervened, and enforcement paused.
- June 2026: the GAAIA draft proposed a three-year freeze on state AI model laws. It is still a draft.
- States passed 109 AI laws by July 1, 2026, despite the pressure.
- OpenAI and Anthropic spent $3.17 million on lobbying in Q2 2026 alone.
- Bottom line: state law is what applies to you today. The federal ceiling is a proposal, not a fact.

